Posted by greg5 on 04-23-2002 08:03 PM:

greg5 Question #144: What the @#$&*@!!! is that?

Serina and I were discussing the finer points of this evening's Roswell (Who died and made you king?)... when suddenly this thing showed up...

Of course WE know what it is... but what do YOU think it is?





Serina (seven of five) Queen of Terrestrial Heiroglyphs
Sparky-who in absentia-had already banished us from the TV room
Greg


Posted by colebear on 04-23-2002 08:07 PM:

Okkkaaaaay I'm lost *Gives Greg her best confused look*

Ahem...But maybe that is because I don't get to see Roswell until Saturday ....Just a guess though.................




Posted by shapeshifter on 04-24-2002 03:08 PM:




Posted by greg5 on 04-24-2002 08:04 PM:

Ooh- Banjo and Garnet- you guys are good!

Yes the Spike signature was to throw everyone off track but it actually does have relevance since the picture could work for Spike explanations as well as for Max explanations. More later when Greg actually explains the explanations.......

And yes Garnet, the special ear enhancements were all mine- didn't think Greg drew them big enough to tell it was Stick Figure Max........

It really is a serious theory.............



.......And by the way, Connor, having been sucked into whatever dimension and subsequently floated by us all on the Nile, is actually with Tess now (since both Angel and Max decided baby chasing wasn't all that interesting)- an adopted Prince of Antar who will grow up a happy Royal with his adopted brother Zan Jr. until he talks to God on Damaras Rock and feels compelled to free his earthly people from the tyranical rule of King Zan Jr and parts the stars to lead his people....oh.wrong story......so Dawn, who works her way up from stealing jewelry to stealing spaceships under the FBI's nose, pilots the thing shapeshifterless (she is after all a key you know) to Antar where she faces the serious dilemna of which young man she should choose- the Demon boy or the King ..........what would her sister do?.........Tess, of course, will have none of it- this alien glowy key thing must be stopped!.......okay I'll stop now- got a teensy bit carried away.........Banjo started it.........

Serina (Seven of Five)


Posted by greg5 on 04-25-2002 07:45 PM:

The disection dissected...

First some facts about the pic:
Serina's contributions are in red and Greg's are in black.
Most of Greg's writing was done upside down, which would explain why it is MORE legible than normal.

The two figures at the top of the diagram, labelled (CadX and Happy Alien King-Pre-Vilandra) represent the DNA of Zan and the Human donor.

The Max figure-the one with the Ferengi ears is of course our beloved hybrid king, sent to earth.

The line coming from CadX represent stuff that went into the hybrid-specifically from the original Zan: a bit of Antaran biology (so he could survive on his home planet), the powers (which als come from the human part of his physiology), and some history (???)... Somewhere in there is also the Royal Seal... or was it?

The line coming from Mr. "HappyAlienKing" is the stuff that Max got from his human donor: Biology (to survive on Earth), his love for Liz, and of course his emotions/humanity... which other aliens (Nacedo-who resented it, and the Clapper-who coveted it...)

When our Max figure gets killed (see: DeadMax inset) the Royal Seal (which is not a slice of Pizza... though I am getting hungry)... moves on to Michael (the figure in the lower corner).

At least that's what we saw... (the dotted line).

But what if the seal didn't come with the hybrid ingredients? What if Dupe-Zan had it? (The solid line leading from the Pizza)...
If Zan had the power seal, when he got killed, did it go to Rath? Or to Lonnie (Ms. Cards to play) or did Max get it?

If Max got Zan's royal seal-did Max already have one? He already had the healing powers... but did he have the seal? Did Max get suddenly stronger when Zan died? Or did one of the other Dupes? Did they notice?

Back to the Michael figure.
Here's where we begin to speculate why Rath would be genetically encoded to inherit the Royal Seal?
What was involved in his position as Counsellor or Second? Could he have been betrorthed to Vilandra as some political accord? Was his station respresentative of that? Was he Prince Rath or Duke Rath before he became Counselor Rath?
Or maybe the Rath separatists had the hybrids encoded, figuring Rath would be a better returning King-especially if the hybrids didn't have much history encoded...

Spike
Of course as soon as we started dissecting Max, Serina bursts: We could do this for Spike too!... hence the name in the corner... which... Greg did tell her to jot down there... to distract the untrained eye... (it was a Katimsish deflection... in other words don't expect a Spike diagram anytime soon... )

Serina (seven of five) Queen of Figure 8
Sparky still wants nothing to do with this
Greg



Posted by shapeshifter on 04-26-2002 04:07 PM:

How about this for order of operations:

Max had the RS (Royal Seal) to begin with because he was the First String King.
If Max had died and Zan was still alive, the Royal Seal would have gone to Zan.
Then, if Zan died, the Royal Seal would go next to Michael, and then, if Michael died, to Rath.

So then, thinking about TEOTW:

If Tess had left, and the Roswell 3 had died, and Zan was already dead, Rath would have taken over the world.

P.S. Glad y'all enjoyed the pic. I did the cartoon at the end of Season One for a prototype character for a teen health Website I was helping design. They never did use the characters.
The background was manipped from a pick by Qfanny for the Archive site we made.
The greg5 challange inspired me to remanip 'em.



Posted by shapeshifter on 04-26-2002 11:32 PM:

Re: gee guys!

quote:
Originally posted by bwampler
i thought that the pic meant that spike was now a roswell fan...so he has two shows he watches: passions and roswell. hehehe you never know we could be hearing spike yell"dont go with tess, max, she only wants to use your body. she is evil"
BTW, on last night's Friends, Joey hummed the same IDOG theme that Jessie & friend hummed in IMAA. Actually, I think I've caught a Roswell reference on nearly every ep of Friends I've seen this season.


Posted by greg5 on 04-27-2002 08:11 AM:

The opposite of the Nile is a town called De Lusion...

quote:
Originally posted by shapeshifter
BTW, on last night's Friends, Joey hummed the same IDOG theme that Jessie & friend hummed in IMAA. Actually, I think I've caught a Roswell reference on nearly every ep of Friends I've seen this season.


OMG!!!

The Friends live in New York!!! The Dupes were from New York!!! Do you think they could be shapeshifters? Or maybe they're the Royal Six!!!

Hey... that could mean that when WE go to the blu convention in Roswell... maybe I should keep an eye out for a New Mexico version of Rachel... vrrrmmm...



Greg


Posted by banjo_pickin_boy on 04-27-2002 08:25 AM:

Fear not, Greg. I'll give you a tour of all the high schools and you can look for a 'Roswellian Rachel' . That just came to me in a flash of genius.

Of course school will be out for the summer, so you might have to cruise the mall. Roswell has one, believe it or not.


Posted by greg5 on 04-27-2002 10:19 AM:

Maybe we ought to try Coffee houses...

After all Rachael is in her twenties (thirties?)... Isabel may be at the mall... heck... maybe we can try both...



Greg



Posted by Melandra on 04-27-2002 04:57 PM:

first off there was an entire episode devoted to Rachell turning thirty years old The One Where They All Thurn Thirty

Secondly, Greg5 you have me so delighted today. I've been avoiding blu all week because I didn't get to see the new eppie until today (saturday) and I'm delighted with all your interesting threads!!

I had to open this thread twice to see your explination next to the drawing.

Back to the Theory at hand

So what is the Royal pecking order, is that the question here? I forget now...

Greg5 order
1. Max
2. Zan
3. Michael
4. Rath
(why arn't any of the women included here???!!)

My idea
What if BOTH Zan and Max had a Royal seal?? It would seem that Zan's seal was passed on to Lonnie rather than Rath, due to their behavior. While Max's seal was passed to Michael. Why then would one group be engineered one way while the other was engineered another way??

Perhaps, that is part of the "defect" mentioned by Lonnie in Meet the Dupes While of course Lonnie felt her group was seperior because they leaned toward their Alien genetics, We feel that Max's group is superior because it leans toward their human genetics. Maybe there is more to it than that.

two ways of passing the seal....

ONE: The Zan Clan was encoded to pass the seal of leadership within the Royal family from Zan to Lonnie. Because the Antarian style of leadership did not require a male to lead. (of course I like this idea myself.)

TWO: The Roswellian group was encoded to pass the seal of leadership first to the men. Because saddly this has historically been the "human" way of doing things.

So Perhaps, one group (Zan's group) was engenired to survive best on Antar, with Antar's code of morals, ethics, and norms. While the other group (Max's group) was engenired to surve best on Earth, with Earth's (human) code of morals, ethics, and norms.

The reason for two groups
Maybe we have figured out the reason for two groups...maybe it wasn't because they "made a mistake" with one group. Maybe it was because they didn't know if the group would ever be able to come back, so they made one group that could survive on Earth forever if they needed to and one group that could survive on Antar if they were able to return.

Or better yet maybe it was because they ment for Max's group TO STAY ON EARTH FOREVER and rule from there, while they ment for Zan's group TO RETURN TO ANTAR, and rule from there. Perhaps they didn't want the two groups to compete against each other for the right to rule, perhaps they ment for them to WORK TOGETHER and bring the UNIVERSE and the 5 planets in the Antar seal to peace.


well maybe they did


Posted by Momo on 04-28-2002 12:05 PM:

Okay, I didn't post earlier because I just got to see the eppy last night. And here's my thoughts. I totally disagree with greg5. I don't think the Dupes ever had the royal seal.

However, what's really interesting to note is that the seal passed to Michael, , NOT Max's son by Tess. Don't you find that interesting? Back to that in a minute.

The reason I think Zan was never involved is that had Zan had the seal, wouldn't have Max had the same reaction as Michael, or anyone else assuming the royal seal? We saw none of that with either Max or Rath ... so it leads me to conclude that Max was always the possessor of the royal seal.

Previously, we have referred to Max's son as his heir. As his heir, Max's son would be the direct male in line to the throne by heredity. I'm assuming that the line is through heredity since Max follows his father as king. So the line, from a genealogical and political standpoint would have been as follows:

1. Max/Zan's dad
2. Zan (pre Max)
3. Max (reborn)
4. Max's son
5. Michael


Now we know that Max's son had already been born months before. So why doesn't the seal pass directly to Max's son? As the immediate heir to the throne, the seal should have gone to Max's son, but it goes to Michael instead. WHY? Does it mean that the baby really isn't Max's after all?

Okay, so the seal goes to Michael. This makes sense if it's the monarchy passes through the male line. Michael, as the betrothed to the princess, would be next in line to the throne, but generally ONLY if there is no male heir. Max has a son. So when the pod squad was engineered, why was this important detail overlooked? It brings into question to validity of Tess' baby as heir.

However, Michael is NOT married to Isabel so the seal, if not passed to Max's son, and there was no male heir would normally go to Isabel. Why didn't it? Did Vilandra's misdeeds come to light and she was passed over in favor of Michael? Or is Michael's royal connection to The House of Antar more than one of by marriage? Perhaps Michael really is a successor to the throne by blood. That is, by birth, Michael is Max & Is' cousin, fathered by one of Max's dad's siblings. If that is the case, Michael would be in direct line to the throne after Max as the next male heir should Max have no male heir.

So my most obvious question is: Why was Max's son overlooked? Does Max have a son or doesn't he? Food for thought.

The other interesting point was that the seal appears on Michael's chest, not his forehead. From MITC, we know the royal seal was imbedded in Max's head. If Michael were the true successor to the throne, shouldn't the royal seal have moved to his head? Why his chest? Well, there might be two reasons.

1. As second in charge, he is seen as "acting" king, that is as temporary king. In this case, maybe he is "acting" as regent for Max's son who bears the royal seal in his head. But I can't buy this because Max takes the seal back, so it implies that there is only ONE royal seal. If there is only one seal, then the seal should have gone straight to Max's son.

2. That each royal member -- Max, Michael, Isabel, and Michael, have a seal imbedded in them that denotes their position in the royal line and each seal is placed in a different position of the body to denote rank. However, if that were the case, then Max should not have been able to strip Michael of his rank.

So I'm back to the beginning. That Michael inherits through a blood connection to The House of Antar rather than marriage. As next in line to the throne, he assumes Max's command and his powers. HOWEVER, we are still left with no explanation why Max's son would be passed over if Max's son is real, legitimate or otherwise.

Anybody else have thoughts on this?


Posted by greg5 on 04-28-2002 12:22 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by Melandra
First off there was an entire episode devoted to Rachell turning thirty years old The One Where They All Thurn Thirty


Solid!!! My age... then again... if Jesse could date Iz... (okay... I'm a little older than Jesse... but he's way taller...)[/b]


quote:
Originally posted by Melandra
Secondly, Greg5 you have me so delighted today. I've been avoiding blu all week because I didn't get to see the new eppie until today (saturday) and I'm delighted with all your interesting threads!!

I had to open this thread twice to see your explination next to the drawing.

Back to the Theory at hand

So what is the Royal pecking order, is that the question here? I forget now...

Greg5 order
1. Max
2. Zan
3. Michael
4. Rath
(why arn't any of the women included here???!!)


Actually WE're not entirely set on OUR order...
WE also recognize that Lonnie may have gotten the Seal and the Power when Zan died...


quote:
Originally posted by Melandra
My idea
What if BOTH Zan and Max had a Royal seal?? It would seem that Zan's seal was passed on to Lonnie rather than Rath, due to their behavior. While Max's seal was passed to Michael. Why then would one group be engineered one way while the other was engineered another way??

I actually support the two Seal theory. I think that when they sent out two sets, both went out ready to take over.

Now how about this:

What if-All three of the non-Zan hybrids could inherit the Seal, but their templates dictated which one actually got it.
Bear with me...

I think the hybrids have a template-that is the foundation for their powers (and memories?) and at some point maybe even personality. But what if there are stages of development to these templates and the one closest to being "mature" is the one who gets the Seal-if Zan cacks...

I also think the template was responsible for Michael's reversion in behavior-back to an Early-episode Michael-or a Michael with less human-training affecting his genetically encoded template.
What does that mean? I think that the template makes them act a certain way and that they had to grow up together (or be properly trained) in order to actually behave like normal people (human or Antaran)-because that kind of stuff maybe you just can't hardwire.

So as we've seen Michael develop, he's become less Rath, and more Michael, but once he got the Seal, he became more Rath... now it's also possible that over time he may have re-learned some of the compassion and empathy that he'd grown into, but because it came so late and was so fragile, the template over-rode it.

Have I lost everyone yet?

quote:
Originally posted by Melandra
Perhaps, that is part of the "defect" mentioned by Lonnie in Meet the Dupes While of course Lonnie felt her group was seperior because they leaned toward their Alien genetics, We feel that Max's group is superior because it leans toward their human genetics. Maybe there is more to it than that.


I'm a firm believer that Lonnie made that up.

quote:
Originally posted by Melandra
two ways of passing the seal....

Very cool.

quote:
Originally posted by Melandra
The reason for two groups

Again... very cool... but here's a thought for you... maybe one set was designed to fight the fight on Earth and one was meant to come back...
Remember the Momogram said that the battle would come to them...
or something like that...

What do you think?



Greg


Posted by greg5 on 04-28-2002 01:16 PM:

It's really a question of PLANNING...

quote:
Originally posted by Momo
Okay, I didn't post earlier because I just got to see the eppy last night. And here's my thoughts. I totally disagree with greg5. I don't think the Dupes ever had the royal seal.

However, what's really interesting to note is that the seal passed to Michael, , NOT Max's son by Tess. Don't you find that interesting? Back to that in a minute.


Not really... because the heir was probably not a contingency that could have been planned for-specifically when talking about the genetic engineering. So if the Seal was encoded into the Zans and receivers were encoded into the rest of the hybrids-that makes sense-because you're working with existing genetic patterns.

Now, if they were to manipulate the Ava's and Zan's reproductive parts to breed to receive the Seal, that might make sense, but might be a dangerous and unthinkable step. It's one thing to clone someone, but what kind of doors does it open up if you start mucking with new entities... especially if they are destined to rule your solar system.

The line of heritage would pass from Zan to an heir. Not the Seal. Presumably the Seal was designed so that a True Zan(s) could be recognized and brought back.

Also remember, the Clapper was surprised that they had bred. Had there been contingencies for that, I think his reaction (and subsequent actions) would have been different. For example, he could have let Max/Zan off the hook. Had there been a contingency for the heir... either the heir would assume the throne or someone would be coming for Zan... either way... the Clapper could have told Max something that would have dissuaded him from wrecking his own life.



quote:
Originally posted by Momo
The reason I think Zan was never involved is that had Zan had the seal, wouldn't have Max had the same reaction as Michael, or anyone else assuming the royal seal? We saw none of that with either Max or Rath ... so it leads me to conclude that Max was always the possessor of the royal seal.


Or Lonnie got it. Which would very nicely explain her ability and desire to take over-as she did.

quote:
Originally posted by Momo
Previously, we have referred to Max's son as his heir. As his heir, Max's son would be the direct male in line to the throne by heredity. I'm assuming that the line is through heredity since Max follows his father as king. So the line, from a genealogical and political standpoint would have been as follows:

1. Max/Zan's dad
2. Zan (pre Max)
3. Max (reborn)
4. Max's son
5. Michael


I would not assume that the Seal (genetically encoded into the line) existed on Antar prior to the hybrids being sent out.
I think more likely, the Seal was implanted to identify the work of the Royal House, and make whichever hybrid returned, the last surviving member of the Royal Four.
It's also unlikely that they would send the lone Seal across the galaxy, when if they COULD/WOULD engineer the offspring, they could instead engineer a Prince (that no one would know to look at because he didn't exist)-hide him away, train him and then whip him out to oppose the enemy. And of course, then he would have the Seal in his skull.


quote:
Originally posted by Momo
Now we know that Max's son had already been born months before. So why doesn't the seal pass directly to Max's son? As the immediate heir to the throne, the seal should have gone to Max's son, but it goes to Michael instead. WHY? Does it mean that the baby really isn't Max's after all?

I'll stick with my theory that the manipulation of genetic OFFSPRING is unthinkable.
But it's also possible that ANY offspring that the hybrids have are going to be born genetically marked... now the problem that creates for Antar is that means Zan is ALIVE... when the offspring returns. If Zan is alive, then the heir can not ascend to the throne-which is currently not held by his faction anyway-so it's fairly irrelevant.
Unless of course Tess lied (to protect Max... think about it) and told them that Zan was dead. But still the problem remains, the powers that would put him on the throne are not in control. Which is why the hybrids were sent away in the first place. Having them born in occupation would be... uh... bad.


quote:
Originally posted by Momo
Okay, so the seal goes to Michael. This makes sense if it's the monarchy passes through the male line. Michael, as the betrothed to the princess, would be next in line to the throne, but generally ONLY if there is no male heir. Max has a son. So when the pod squad was engineered, why was this important detail overlooked? It brings into question to validity of Tess' baby as heir.

However, Michael is NOT married to Isabel so the seal, if not passed to Max's son, and there was no male heir would normally go to Isabel. Why didn't it? Did Vilandra's misdeeds come to light and she was passed over in favor of Michael? Or is Michael's royal connection to The House of Antar more than one of by marriage? Perhaps Michael really is a successor to the throne by blood. That is, by birth, Michael is Max & Is' cousin, fathered by one of Max's dad's siblings. If that is the case, Michael would be in direct line to the throne after Max as the next male heir should Max have no male heir.


Actually, it's uncommon to be able ascend to a throne via marriage-that is unless you previously had some claim to the throne.

Which raises the question... WHO WAS RATH? Like Momo alludes to, where does Rath's connection to the throne lie? Is he a cousin or a waring family-who could claim the throne? Where did Rath's followers (like Courtney) come from? Why can't Kivar claim the throne?

Let's think about this BETROTHAL then for a second... if Rath already had a legitimate claim to the throne, why betroth him to Vilandra? Unless it's to bring about peace or some other accord?


quote:
Originally posted by Momo
So my most obvious question is: Why was Max's son overlooked? Does Max have a son or doesn't he? Food for thought.

Two points stand in the way of proving or disproving the son:
1. COULD/WOULD the engineers go the extent to encode the heir to receive the Seal. And if they could-would it STILL go to a more mature adult first?
--Or would they encode any offspring of Zan with a particular identifiable mark and hope that the Seal came back with one of the hybrids.
2. Is the Seal ONLY relevant to the hybrids?
--If the child was unable to survive in Earth's atmosphere, then that makes it unlikely that any thought was given to the hybrids breeding off planet.

So whether the Seal passed to Rath or Villandra-would it have passed to Tess? may have no bearing on any claim of birthright to the heir. Likewise, the heir may not need the Seal to be able to ascend.


quote:
Originally posted by Momo
The other interesting point was that the seal appears on Michael's chest, not his forehead. From MITC, we know the royal seal was imbedded in Max's head. If Michael were the true successor to the throne, shouldn't the royal seal have moved to his head? Why his chest? Well, there might be two reasons.

1. As second in charge, he is seen as "acting" king, that is as temporary king. In this case, maybe he is "acting" as regent for Max's son who bears the royal seal in his head. But I can't buy this because Max takes the seal back, so it implies that there is only ONE royal seal. If there is only one seal, then the seal should have gone straight to Max's son.

2. That each royal member -- Max, Michael, Isabel, and Michael, have a seal imbedded in them that denotes their position in the royal line and each seal is placed in a different position of the body to denote rank. However, if that were the case, then Max should not have been able to strip Michael of his rank.


I'd go with the first one, and the second part as an explanation to where it was.
It makes sense that for someone who (presumably looks like Zan) to ascend, the Seal would be hidden. But for someone who is not Zan or does not look like Zan, the Seal may need to be shown more often and more liberally to garner support.



quote:
Originally posted by Momo
So I'm back to the beginning. That Michael inherits through a blood connection to The House of Antar rather than marriage. As next in line to the throne, he assumes Max's command and his powers. HOWEVER, we are still left with no explanation why Max's son would be passed over if Max's son is real, legitimate or otherwise.


I do not believe that Rath has a DIRECT blood-tie to the throne, but more likely a political claim. If he had a blood-tie, he would likely- not be Zan's second in command but instead, he (or his advisors) would have squirrelled him and Villandra as far away from Zan as possible.
However, if his position was one that was viewed as coveted and respected, it could have been used to unite a people-particularly if there had been some dispute to the legitimacy of Zan's family's claim to the throne. But if Rath was a "cousin" then the line is clear and his presence there would be... to keep him under thumb.

And I think there are great explanations for Max's son not to recieve the Seal, not the least of which are (to recap):
1. The heir was probably not engineered to recieve it. Had it been engineered to do so, it would have FIRST been engineered to survive a birth away from Antar.
2. A different type of encoding could have been used instead, to identify a Zan heir-something Zan would have passed along with his DNA... probably something simple... and there's nothing to say that whatever it is didn't show some sign of coming to life when the last Zan died...



quote:
Originally posted by Momo Anybody else have thoughts on this?




I had thoughts...

I think that we know too little about : 1) what's going on with the Heir; and 2) about the relationship between Zan and Rath (which wasn't really as impotant of a question until Rath got the Seal...) to presume why the heir was skipped.

Although I do think the concept that the Seal DID go to Rath tells SOMETHING...
What...



Greg


Posted by shapeshifter on 04-28-2002 04:40 PM:

ITA with greg5 (whichever of 5) that the reason Max's son didn't get the seal would be that it was an engineered thing. I remember Kal's dismay/shock about Max mating with another alien--maybe it can only be passed to a human/alien cross.
Hmmm...maybe part of the Tess/baby plot was to cut off the royal line.

Also, re Michael being next in line: this would be a military strategy. He was "Second in Command." But yeah, definitely a little sexist.


Posted by Melandra on 04-29-2002 02:21 PM:

you give me lots to ponder Momo and Greg, lots to ponder...


Posted by ~*~Heather~*~ on 04-29-2002 02:29 PM:

quote:
Originally posted by GinNJuice
*rubs her head and tries to revive the brain cells lost within this thread*

um ... well ... yeah what serina said sounds good

hmm...ummm...yeah whats Gin said


Posted by garnet on 04-29-2002 08:12 PM:

hey who let all of the theory people in......

ouch my head!!


All times are GMT -6 hours. The time now is 03:19 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.2.0
Copyright © Jelsoft Enterprises Limited 2000, 2001.